# Validator Status Investigation

**Last Updated:** 2026-01-31  
**Document Version:** 1.0  
**Status:** Active Documentation

---

**Date**: 2025-01-20  
**Status**: 🔍 **INVESTIGATING**

---

## Issue

Validators 1000-1002 are showing as "unknown" with error:
```
Configuration file 'nodes/ml110/lxc/1000.conf' does not exist
```

This suggests validators don't exist on Proxmox host 192.168.11.10.

---

## Findings

### Validators Found on Proxmox Host 192.168.11.10
- **Validator-1003**: ✅ Running (VMID 1003)
- **Validator-1004**: ✅ Running (VMID 1004)

### Validators NOT Found on Proxmox Host 192.168.11.10
- **Validator-1000**: ❌ Not found
- **Validator-1001**: ❌ Not found
- **Validator-1002**: ❌ Not found

### Possible Locations
1. **Different Proxmox Host**: Validators 1000-1002 may be on a different Proxmox node
2. **Different VMID Range**: Validators may have different VMIDs
3. **Not Deployed**: Validators may not have been created yet

---

## QBFT Consensus Requirements

### Typical QBFT Requirements
- **Majority Consensus**: Requires (N/2 + 1) validators
- **For 5 Validators**: Need at least 3 validators running
- **Current Status**: Only 2/5 validators running

### Impact
- **Block Production**: May be stalled with only 2/5 validators
- **Consensus**: Cannot reach majority without 3+ validators
- **Transactions**: Cannot be confirmed without block production

---

## Solutions

### Option 1: Locate Missing Validators
- Check other Proxmox hosts
- Verify if validators have different VMIDs
- Check if validators are named differently

### Option 2: Check if 2 Validators Can Work
- Some QBFT configurations allow fewer validators
- Check genesis/consensus configuration
- Test if blocks can be produced with 2 validators

### Option 3: Deploy Missing Validators
- If validators don't exist, deploy them
- Configure them to join the network
- Ensure they sync properly

---

## Next Steps

1. ✅ Check if validators 1000-1002 exist elsewhere
2. ✅ Verify validators 1003-1004 are fully active
3. ⏳ Test if blocks can be produced with 2 validators
4. ⏳ Locate or deploy missing validators if needed

---

**Status**: Investigation in progress  
**Priority**: Determine if blocks can be produced with current validators