# Security Audit Preparation - Smart Accounts

**Date**: 2026-01-26  
**Network**: ChainID 138 (SMOM-DBIS-138)

---

## Overview

This document outlines the security audit preparation for Smart Accounts Kit integration contracts.

---

## Contracts to Audit

### 1. AccountWalletRegistryExtended

**File**: `contracts/smart-accounts/AccountWalletRegistryExtended.sol`

**Key Functions**:
- `linkSmartAccount()` - Links smart account to fiat account
- `isSmartAccount()` - Checks if wallet is smart account
- `setSmartAccountFactory()` - Updates factory address
- `setEntryPoint()` - Updates EntryPoint address

**Security Concerns**:
- Access control (role-based)
- Input validation
- Smart account verification
- Reentrancy protection

---

### 2. Smart Accounts Kit Contracts (External)

**Contracts**:
- EntryPoint (ERC-4337)
- AccountFactory
- Paymaster (optional)

**Note**: These are external contracts from MetaMask Smart Accounts Kit. Review their security audits.

---

## Audit Checklist

### Access Control

- [ ] Role-based access control implemented correctly
- [ ] Admin functions protected
- [ ] Role assignment verified
- [ ] Role revocation works correctly

### Input Validation

- [ ] Zero address checks
- [ ] Parameter validation
- [ ] Array bounds checking
- [ ] Type validation

### Smart Account Verification

- [ ] Contract detection works correctly
- [ ] Smart account validation
- [ ] Address format validation
- [ ] Duplicate prevention

### Reentrancy Protection

- [ ] Reentrancy guards in place
- [ ] State changes before external calls
- [ ] Checks-Effects-Interactions pattern

### Gas Optimization

- [ ] Gas-efficient storage patterns
- [ ] Loop optimization
- [ ] Unnecessary operations removed

### Event Emission

- [ ] All state changes emit events
- [ ] Event parameters complete
- [ ] Indexed parameters for filtering

---

## Known Security Considerations

### 1. Smart Account Verification

**Risk**: EOA could be mistaken for smart account

**Mitigation**: 
- Check `extcodesize` > 0
- Verify contract has code

### 2. Factory Address Updates

**Risk**: Malicious factory address

**Mitigation**:
- Admin-only function
- Verify factory address before update
- Consider timelock for critical updates

### 3. EntryPoint Address Updates

**Risk**: Malicious EntryPoint address

**Mitigation**:
- Admin-only function
- Verify EntryPoint address
- Consider timelock for critical updates

---

## Testing Requirements

### Unit Tests

- [ ] Access control tests
- [ ] Input validation tests
- [ ] Smart account detection tests
- [ ] Edge case tests

### Integration Tests

- [ ] End-to-end flow tests
- [ ] Multi-contract interaction tests
- [ ] Failure mode tests

### Fuzz Tests

- [ ] Fuzz input parameters
- [ ] Fuzz state transitions
- [ ] Fuzz edge cases

### Invariant Tests

- [ ] State invariants
- [ ] Access control invariants
- [ ] Data consistency invariants

---

## Audit Deliverables

### 1. Code Documentation

- [ ] NatSpec comments on all functions
- [ ] Architecture documentation
- [ ] Security considerations documented

### 2. Test Coverage

- [ ] Unit test coverage > 90%
- [ ] Integration test coverage > 80%
- [ ] Fuzz test coverage
- [ ] Invariant test coverage

### 3. Security Documentation

- [ ] Threat model
- [ ] Security assumptions
- [ ] Known limitations
- [ ] Risk assessment

---

## Recommended Audit Firms

### Smart Contract Auditors

1. **Trail of Bits**
   - Experience with account abstraction
   - ERC-4337 expertise

2. **OpenZeppelin**
   - Smart account experience
   - Access control expertise

3. **Consensys Diligence**
   - MetaMask integration experience
   - Security best practices

4. **CertiK**
   - Comprehensive audits
   - Formal verification

---

## Audit Scope

### In Scope

- AccountWalletRegistryExtended contract
- Integration with existing AccountWalletRegistry
- Smart account linking logic
- Access control implementation

### Out of Scope

- MetaMask Smart Accounts Kit contracts (external)
- EntryPoint contract (external, already audited)
- AccountFactory contract (external, already audited)
- Paymaster contract (external, optional)

---

## Pre-Audit Checklist

### Code Quality

- [ ] Code formatted (forge fmt)
- [ ] No compiler warnings
- [ ] All tests passing
- [ ] Documentation complete

### Security

- [ ] Slither analysis run
- [ ] Mythril analysis run
- [ ] Manual security review
- [ ] Known issues documented

### Testing

- [ ] Unit tests complete
- [ ] Integration tests complete
- [ ] Fuzz tests complete
- [ ] Coverage > 90%

---

## Post-Audit Actions

### 1. Address Findings

- [ ] Review audit report
- [ ] Prioritize findings
- [ ] Fix critical issues
- [ ] Fix high-priority issues
- [ ] Document medium/low issues

### 2. Re-testing

- [ ] Re-run all tests
- [ ] Verify fixes
- [ ] Update documentation

### 3. Re-audit (if needed)

- [ ] Schedule re-audit for critical fixes
- [ ] Verify all issues resolved

---

## Resources

- [OpenZeppelin Security Best Practices](https://docs.openzeppelin.com/contracts/security)
- [Consensys Best Practices](https://consensys.github.io/smart-contract-best-practices/)
- [Trail of Bits Security Guide](https://github.com/crytic/building-secure-contracts)

---

**Last Updated**: 2026-01-26
