d-bis/Sankofa
4
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
adb48eb76a1759bfcd75cbf8fa23011a94d2a178
Sankofa/docs/proxmox/archive/GAPS_AND_PLACEHOLDERS.md
defiQUG a8106e24ee Remove obsolete audit and deployment documentation files 
- Deleted outdated files related to repository audit and deployment status, including AUDIT_COMPLETE.md, AUDIT_FIXES_APPLIED.md, FINAL_DEPLOYMENT_STATUS.md, and others.
- Cleaned up documentation to streamline the repository and improve clarity for future maintenance.
- Updated README and other relevant documentation to reflect the removal of these files.
2025-12-12 19:42:31 -08:00

7.6 KiB
Raw Blame History

Proxmox Gaps and Placeholders Report

This document lists all identified gaps, placeholders, and incomplete implementations in the Proxmox infrastructure setup.

Critical Placeholders (Must Fix Before Production)

1. Cloudflare Tunnel Configurations

Files:

  • cloudflare/tunnel-configs/proxmox-site-1.yaml
  • cloudflare/tunnel-configs/proxmox-site-2.yaml
  • cloudflare/tunnel-configs/proxmox-site-3.yaml

Issues:

  • yourdomain.com appears in 15+ locations (hostnames)
  • .local addresses used instead of actual IPs/hostnames (e.g., pve1.local:8006)
  • Tunnel credentials files not generated (/etc/cloudflared/proxmox-site-*-tunnel.json)

Impact: Tunnels will not work without proper configuration

Tasks: TASK-021, TASK-022, TASK-030

2. Provider Configuration

File: crossplane-provider-proxmox/examples/provider-config.yaml

Issues:

  • Line 11: "password": "your-proxmox-password" - placeholder password
  • Credentials should use API tokens instead of passwords

Impact: Provider cannot authenticate to Proxmox

Tasks: TASK-023, TASK-039

3. Container Registry

File: crossplane-provider-proxmox/config/provider.yaml

Issues:

  • Line 24: image: yourregistry/crossplane-provider-proxmox:latest
  • No actual registry configured
  • Image not built/pushed

Impact: Provider cannot be deployed

Tasks: TASK-024, TASK-034

4. Organization Namespace

Files:

  • gitops/infrastructure/claims/vm-claim-example.yaml (line 1: proxmox.yourorg.io)
  • gitops/infrastructure/xrds/virtualmachine.yaml (lines 4, 6: proxmox.yourorg.io)

Issues:

  • yourorg.io placeholder not replaced
  • Should be proxmox.sankofa.nexus to match provider

Impact: GitOps manifests won't work correctly

Tasks: TASK-025

Implementation Gaps

5. Proxmox API Client

File: crossplane-provider-proxmox/pkg/proxmox/client.go

Issues:

  • Line 129: createVM() - TODO: Implement actual Proxmox API call
  • Line 154: updateVM() - TODO: Implement actual Proxmox API call
  • Line 175: deleteVM() - TODO: Implement actual Proxmox API call
  • Line 200: getVMStatus() - TODO: Implement actual Proxmox API call
  • Line 298: ListNodes() - Returns placeholder []string{"node1", "node2"}
  • Line 305: ListVMs() - Returns placeholder []VM{}
  • Line 312: ListStorages() - Returns placeholder []Storage{}
  • Line 319: ListNetworks() - Returns placeholder []Network{}
  • Line 331: GetClusterInfo() - Returns placeholder data
  • No HTTP client implementation
  • No authentication handling
  • No request/response logging

Impact: Provider cannot actually manage Proxmox resources

Tasks: TASK-008, TASK-026

6. Metrics Collector

File: crossplane-provider-proxmox/pkg/controller/vmscaleset/controller.go

Issues:

  • Line 49: metricsCollector := metrics.NewCollector(nil) // Placeholder
  • No actual metrics collection implemented

Impact: No metrics for VM scale set operations

Tasks: TASK-027

Configuration Gaps

7. DNS Configuration

Issues:

  • No DNS records configured for:
    • pve1.sankofa.nexus
    • pve4.sankofa.nexus
    • pve7.sankofa.nexus
    • pve1-api.sankofa.nexus, pve4-api.sankofa.nexus, pve7-api.sankofa.nexus
    • pve1-metrics.sankofa.nexus, pve4-metrics.sankofa.nexus, pve7-metrics.sankofa.nexus
  • No mapping between IP addresses (192.168.11.10, 192.168.11.11) and hostnames

Impact: Cannot access Proxmox via hostnames, Cloudflare tunnels won't work

Tasks: TASK-029, TASK-007

8. Resource Names

Issues:

  • Storage pool names assumed: local-lvm (not verified)
  • Network bridge names assumed: vmbr0 (not verified)
  • OS template names assumed: ubuntu-22.04-cloud (not verified)
  • ✅ Node names verified and updated: ML110-01 (192.168.11.10), R630-01 (192.168.11.11)

Impact: VM deployments will fail if names don't match

Tasks: TASK-028, TASK-037

9. SSH Keys

Files:

  • crossplane-provider-proxmox/examples/vm-example.yaml (lines 21, 23)
  • gitops/infrastructure/claims/vm-claim-example.yaml (line 22)

Issues:

  • Placeholder SSH keys: ssh-rsa AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQ...
  • Not actual keys

Impact: Cannot SSH into VMs created from examples

Tasks: TASK-032

Missing Resources

10. Test VM Manifests

Issues:

  • No test-vm-instance-1.yaml file
  • No test-vm-instance-2.yaml file
  • Referenced in TASK-015 but not created

Impact: Cannot test VM deployment

Tasks: TASK-031

11. Grafana Dashboards

Issues:

  • No Proxmox dashboard JSON files
  • Referenced in monitoring setup but not created
  • Location: infrastructure/monitoring/dashboards/ (may not exist)

Impact: No visual monitoring of Proxmox infrastructure

Tasks: TASK-035

12. Operational Runbooks

Issues:

  • No runbooks created
  • Referenced in TASK-018 but not created
  • Location: docs/runbooks/ (may not exist)

Impact: No operational procedures documented

Tasks: TASK-036

Build and Development Gaps

13. Makefile

Issues:

  • No Makefile in crossplane-provider-proxmox/
  • Build process not documented
  • No standardized build targets

Impact: Inconsistent build process

Tasks: TASK-034

14. Go Module Paths

File: crossplane-provider-proxmox/go.mod

Issues:

  • Module path may not match actual repository
  • Imports may need updating
  • Dependencies may be outdated

Impact: Build may fail, imports may break

Tasks: TASK-033

Security Gaps

15. TLS Configuration

Issues:

  • insecureSkipTLSVerify: false in configs but certificates may not be valid
  • No certificate management documented
  • No certificate rotation process

Impact: Security risk if TLS not properly configured

Tasks: TASK-038

16. API Token Management

Issues:

  • No token rotation process
  • No token expiration policies
  • No documentation on token permissions
  • Tokens may have excessive permissions

Impact: Security risk, potential unauthorized access

Tasks: TASK-039

Summary

By Category

  • Configuration Placeholders: 5 tasks (TASK-021 to TASK-025)
  • Implementation Gaps: 3 tasks (TASK-026 to TASK-028)
  • DNS/Network: 2 tasks (TASK-029, TASK-030)
  • Missing Resources: 3 tasks (TASK-031, TASK-032, TASK-035)
  • Build/Dev: 2 tasks (TASK-033, TASK-034)
  • Documentation: 2 tasks (TASK-036, TASK-037)
  • Security: 2 tasks (TASK-038, TASK-039)

By Priority

  • Critical (Blocks Deployment): 15 tasks
  • High (Needed for Production): 4 tasks
  • Medium (Improves Operations): 0 tasks

Total Gaps Identified

  • 19 new tasks added (TASK-021 to TASK-039)
  • Total tasks: 39 (original 20 + 19 gaps)

Next Steps

  1. Immediate: Fix critical placeholders (TASK-021 to TASK-025)
  2. Short-term: Complete implementations (TASK-026 to TASK-028)
  3. Medium-term: Set up infrastructure (TASK-029 to TASK-032)
  4. Long-term: Documentation and security (TASK-033 to TASK-039)

Files Requiring Updates

  1. cloudflare/tunnel-configs/proxmox-site-*.yaml (3 files)
  2. crossplane-provider-proxmox/examples/provider-config.yaml
  3. crossplane-provider-proxmox/config/provider.yaml
  4. crossplane-provider-proxmox/pkg/proxmox/client.go
  5. crossplane-provider-proxmox/pkg/controller/vmscaleset/controller.go
  6. gitops/infrastructure/claims/vm-claim-example.yaml
  7. gitops/infrastructure/xrds/virtualmachine.yaml
  8. crossplane-provider-proxmox/examples/vm-example.yaml

Notes

  • All placeholders should be replaced before production deployment
  • All TODO comments should be addressed
  • All placeholder implementations should be completed
  • Security gaps should be addressed before exposing to internet
  • DNS and network configuration must be completed for Cloudflare tunnels to work
Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink